Voting: Bocchi-chan to be retained as admin or not | Fandom

Shades of Mundane·3/8/2016 in General Discussion (Wiki)

Voting: Bocchi-chan to be retained as admin or not

Initial appeal here: http://narutoprofile.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:15551

This topic is made for people to cast their votes whether Bocchiere (User:Bocchi-chan) should keep his admin rights or should be demoted. When voting, please use this format:

SL name: |in-game name in Shinobi Legends|

Should Bocchiere be retained or removed: |Indicate Retain or Remove|

Reason/Justification: |This section should indicate why you think he should keep his admin rights or not. Please be reminded that we are talking about his capability to handle the job as an admin here in our wikia. If you need to cite examples, you can show screenshots.|

VOTES:

RETAIN: 6

(Shadow, Nigiri, Mieko, Selene, Hotaru, UettoSenju)

REMOVE: 8

(Warren, Chinote, Kayenta, Xiarawst, Ice, Hobbygobby, Koji, Lonewarrior)

~~Notes on voting:~~

~~1. This will be updated as votes are being tallied. I will include the names of those who voted for all to see.~~

2. Votes with no reasons/justifications will not be counted. We need everyone's output to sort out this issue. Reasons like "Because he's nice to me", "We're friends" are not helpful, are irrelevant to this topic and will not be counted.

3. Those who do not have wikia accounts can send in their votes through PM in the SL site. Send them to me (Sensō no Yomi) and I will screenshot and copy-paste it here to be included (if they are counted as valid votes).

~~4. Voting will end on March 18th, 2016 (That will be March 19th on my time). I will be putting up a post that will indicate votes will no longer be accepted.~~

(Edited by Shades of Mundane)

0

Bocchi-chan·3/7/2016

Kaitohozuki wrote:

trying to enforce this wikia as law on the site and bullying others

Myself and Yomi will not be voting to keep things fair but that doesn't mean I'm making no comments. That is a blatant lie. I said many times I have no power on SL and do not care what people do, claim, or rp on SL. My only concern was enforcing the rules on the wiki as I knew them.

(Edited by Bocchi-chan)

0

Kaitohozuki·3/7/2016

Bocchi-chan wrote:

Kaitohozuki wrote:
trying to enforce this wikia as law on the site and bullying others

Myself and Yomi will not be voting to keep things fair but that doesn't mean I'm making no comments. That is a blatant lie. I said many times I have no power on SL and do not care what people do, claim, or rp on SL. My only concern was enforcing the rules on the wiki as I knew them.

I'm sorry but I'll have disagree with you here, as there are numerous instances on the site where you have gone out of your way to try and enforce your little 'rules' (which Yomi had to call you out on so don't try setting yourself up with her now you've been told to play nicely with her) from this wikia, resulting arguments there. I've attached below just one recent example of your behavior towards those who have attempted to stand up to you, and have lead to creation of this current situation. I would also encourage any other members to share other screenshots of commentary or messages which further show this point.

Further more before you resume your usual tactic of claiming unfair treatment by the moderators, and Ace is the only good mod, I specifically showed Ace this post before I made it, and he agreed with the points made there in, as we are united in purpose on this subject.

(Edited by Kaitohozuki)

0

Bocchi-chan·3/7/2016

Yet you provide no proof of any such numerous examples. Just like Kiri provided no evidence of anything either, just their own thoughts and opinions about me. Yeah the people "standing up" to me. Ok. Manipulate however you want man. It's all up in the air now and we just need to see where everything falls.

(Edited by Bocchi-chan)

0

Zuasaki·3/7/2016

SL name: 六代目雲影 Koji

Should Bocchiere be retained or removed: Remove

Reason/Justification: Abuse and misue of Admin power, harassment to peers, and breaching all of the Admin Accountability rules that were set up by the Wikia staff.

(Edited by Zuasaki)

0

Bocchi-chan·3/7/2016

The voting can cease now, I've removed all admin powers from my acccount, I should just be a regular user now, if Yomi could double check though that would be great.

(Edited by Bocchi-chan)

0

Ryun69·3/7/2016

Was gonna vote to retain, but apparently the vote would not have mattered.

(Edited by Ryun69)

0

Shades of Mundane·3/7/2016

Wikia-vote005 — Mieko's vote

Wikia-vote004 — Selene's vote

Wikia-vote006 — Hotaru's vote

Wikia-vote007 — LonewarrioroftheAbyss's vote

UettoSenju's vote

All sent through PM and shown for transparency.

(Edited by Shades of Mundane)

0

Shades of Mundane·3/8/2016

Bocchi-chan wrote: The voting can cease now, I've removed all admin powers from my acccount, I should just be a regular user now, if Yomi could double check though that would be great.

Wikia-scrn001

Wikia-scrn002

Double checked and uploaded screenshots for confirmation

(Edited by Shades of Mundane)

0

Bocchi-chan·3/8/2016

Just as a point of reference, it says I changed from bureacrat, admin, and poweruser to just poweruser. As you can see in the first screenshot there is no option to make someone a power user. It is something wiki central does and it is a posistion that does not actually grant any abilities, just in case people are scared I'm trying to fool them by keeping one high level posistion or something.

(Edited by Bocchi-chan)

0

Shades of Mundane·3/8/2016

Bocchi-chan wrote: Just as a point of reference, it says I changed from bureacrat, admin, and poweruser to just poweruser. As you can see in the first screenshot there is no option to make someone a power user. It is something wiki central does and it is a posistion that does not actually grant any abilities, just in case people are scared I'm trying to fool them by keeping one high level posistion or something.

Powerusers are defined as members who actively edit/participate here in the wikia. It's an automatic flag, for everyone's information.

http://answers.wikia.com/wiki/What_is_the_poweruser_user_group_on_Wikia

http://community.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:810670

Also, given Bocchiere's resignation from the admin spot and having talked to him about the matter, this poll will now be closed. Votes will not be accepted from this point on.

(Edited by Shades of Mundane)

What do you think?